How to Choose a Home Tutor: Questions to Ask Before the First Lesson | Tutor Circle
← Back to TC Blog

How to Choose a Home Tutor: Questions to Ask Before the First Lesson

27 October 2026 · Tutor Circle

A good match starts before anyone sits down. Write the gap in one sentence, ask six questions, and decide in advance what lesson one and lesson four are for. Liking the tutor is part of it. It is not the check.

A home tutor and a primary school child at a dining table with one worksheet between them
Lesson one should start with the child trying a question, not with a speech about the tutor’s method.
Before you ask for names
One sentence: level, paper, and the topic that is loose
Before lesson one
A named paper, a plan for four lessons, a rate, a way to stop
Lesson one
The child does one question. The tutor says what went wrong
Lesson four
A new question of the same type. The child can start
If it is wrong
Ask for another tutor. Do not add a second subject to hide it

Write the gap first

“Primary 6, needs help” produces a general tutor. “Primary 6 science, explain questions, the child names the topic and misses the because” produces a science tutor who has marked that paper. “Sec 3 Additional Mathematics, differentiation, the algebra is fine” produces a different person again. Put the sentence on the request. The guides on this site are full of those sentences: science phrasing, A Math against E Math, Chinese oral.

Tutor type is a separate choice from subject. An ex-MOE teacher, a full-time tutor and a student tutor fit different gaps, and they sit in different rate bands. That comparison is on the tutor types page. A centre is a different product again, compared on the home tuition and tuition centre page.

Questions before the first lesson

Ask these of the tutor you are about to meet, or read them off the profile before you accept the match. Profiles that reach you through Tutor Circle have already been checked for identity and background. [2] The questions below are about fit, which a check cannot decide for you.

Table 1. Six questions. A useful answer is specific. A vague answer is information too.
AskA useful answerA weak answer
Which paper at this level have you taught in the last year?A named paper and year“All subjects, all levels”
What will you look at in lesson one?One question from the script you describedA plan to “see how the child is” with no task
What will the first four lessons not cover?The topics they are leaving alone“We will finish the syllabus”
What is the rate, the length, and when is it paid?Numbers inside the band for this level and tutor typeA rate that changes after you have said yes
Where do you teach, or is this online?A place and a time the family can keepA slot that needs an hour of travel the child does not have
How do we stop if it is the wrong fit?Another tutor, or a clean end, without a long lock-inA package you cannot leave

The hourly bands are published on the rate table. [1] Agree the rate before lesson one. Renegotiating it in week three is how a clear arrangement becomes an argument.

What lesson one should show

A parent sitting back from the table, watching a tutor and a child begin a lesson
Stay for the first twenty minutes of a primary lesson. You are there to see whether anyone looks at the working.

Stay for the first twenty minutes if the child is in primary school. You are not there to teach. You are there to see whether the assessment happens. Tick what you actually saw. Four ticks is a lesson that did its job. One tick is a pleasant hour.

  • The tutor asked the child to try one question from the weak topic before explaining it.
  • The tutor looked at the working, not only at the final number or the oral fluency.
  • The child spoke for part of the time. A lesson in which only the tutor talks has not found the gap.
  • At the end, the tutor could say the gap in one sentence you understood.
  • The homework is one short task of that same type. A stack of worksheets is not an assessment.
  • The child was willing to ask a question. Silence can be shyness. Silence plus a blank page is the gap.

The check at lesson four

A tutor's hand and a child's hand over an open exercise book
Lesson four uses a new question of the same type. The exercise book should show a start, not the same blank.

Tell the tutor at lesson one that lesson four is a review. Put a new question of the same type on the table. Do not use the question from lesson one. Memory of that conversation is not progress.

Table 2. How to read lesson four. Do this with the exercise book open.
What you seeWhat it meansWhat to do
The child starts without being shown the first lineThe method is in placeContinue. Move to the next topic only after a second clean question
The method is right and the arithmetic slipsA new error, which is a better problemStay with this tutor. Slow the questions down
The same blank as lesson oneThe plan did not landAsk the tutor what changes in lesson five. If the answer is “more practice”, change tutor
A different topic has been taught, and the original gap is untouchedThe month was spent on the tutor’s favourite chapterReturn to the sentence you wrote at the start, or ask for another match

Changing tutor is a normal outcome of a four-lesson check. It is not a verdict on the child. Say what lesson four showed when you ask for the next name, so the next person does not repeat the same four weeks. Parents pay the tutor for the lessons taught. There is no separate parent fee for the match.

Questions parents ask

What should I ask a tutor before the first lesson?

Which paper they have taught at this level in the last year, what they will look at in lesson one, what the first four lessons will not try to finish, the rate and the length, and how you will both know it is working. “I teach all levels” is a weak answer. A named paper is a useful one.

What should happen in the first lesson?

The tutor should watch the child do one question from the weak topic before teaching it. By the end, the tutor should be able to say, in a sentence a parent understands, what went wrong. A first lesson that is only a speech about the tutor’s method has not assessed the child.

How do I know after a month whether to continue?

At lesson four, give a new question of the same type. The child should be able to start without the tutor pointing at the first line. Errors that remain should be new ones, such as a slip in arithmetic, not the same blank method as lesson one. The same blank method means the plan or the tutor needs to change.

Does Tutor Circle charge parents a fee to match a tutor?

Parents pay the tutor for lessons. Tutor Circle matches the tutor. If the first tutor is the wrong fit, ask for another name. The rate bands by level and tutor type are on the rate table.

Is a trial lesson enough?

A single lesson can show whether the child will talk, and whether the tutor looks at the working. It cannot show progress. Use lesson one as the assessment, and lesson four as the review. Stopping after one awkward lesson is reasonable if the tutor will not say what the gap is. Stopping because the child was tired after school is not the same information.

Sources

  1. Tutor Circle, home tuition rates in Singapore, by level and tutor type. The rate you agree should sit inside a band you have already seen, for the level and the tutor type you asked for. https://tutorcircle.sg/home-tuition-rates-singapore
  2. Tutor Circle, how tutor profiles are checked before a match, including identity, qualifications and teaching background. https://tutorcircle.sg/how-we-check-tutors

Related guides